Pegasus: Bay Ridge’s Go To Brunch Spot
- Mitch Levin
- 14 minutes ago
- 3 min read
Pegasus : Bay Ridge’s Go To Brunch Spot
You know those weekends where you just crave that perfect, lazy brunch—the kind that turns into the highlight of your whole day? That’s exactly what my partner and I were searching for last Saturday, and we headed straight for Pegasus Restaurant on 3rd Ave. The place has a reputation for turning out breakfast classics with a modern, flavorful twist.
This spot isn't a sleepy old diner; it's a dynamic, modern brunch destination that has totally elevated the neighborhood’s breakfast scene. We walked in curious and left completely satisfied. It truly is the king of its domain.
The Ambiance: Cozy, Buzzing, and Worth the Wait
The first thing that struck us was the atmosphere. We had to wait a short time for a table, but the energy of the place made it fly by! Waiting gave us a great opportunity to watch the hustle and bustle of the dining room.
The Vibe: Pegasus does a fantastic job of blending a cozy, homey comfort with a trendy, updated aesthetic. The space feels bright and inviting, filled with the murmur of happy conversations. It's lively and a bit bustling, but once we were tucked into our booth, it felt intimate and relaxed. We loved the large windows that let in plenty of natural light, perfect for a mid-morning meal.
The Crowd: The place was packed, which only confirmed the popularity of the spot. We saw families, couples, and friends enjoying their meals. Everyone seemed to be having a wonderful time sharing plates and laughing over coffee.
The Service: Even amidst the brunch rush, the service was fantastic. Our server was attentive and friendly, getting our coffee order in immediately and keeping the refills coming. That warm greeting and efficient attention really added to the experience. We never felt rushed, even though the dining room was full.
Our Feast: Indulgent Sweets and Savory Kicks
We decided the best approach was a "sweet and savory" split, ensuring we covered all the bases. The menu is massive, making it tough to choose, but our dual strategy worked perfectly.
The Savory Star: The "Kick A" Benedict
My partner immediately zeroed in on the Kick A Benedict. It starts with country ham and perfectly poached eggs on toasted ciabatta, but the real star is that spicy hollandaise sauce. The sauce was vibrant and creamy, coating the perfectly runny egg yolk.
The sauce gave a fantastic, slow-burn heat that cut through the richness of the egg yolk and ham without overpowering it. It was impeccably executed—a bold, flavorful twist on an absolute brunch classic. We both agreed the spicy hollandaise is their secret weapon!
The Sweet Indulgence: Bananas Foster French Toast
I couldn’t resist the visually stunning Bananas Foster French Toast. The generous portion arrived looking like an absolute dessert.
The foundation was thick, delicious Challah bread, perfectly soaked and griddled. But the topping! The caramelized bananas were tender and sweet, draped in a rich, buttery rum maple sauce. It felt decadent, like eating dessert for breakfast, and was one of the most luxurious French toasts I’ve ever had. It’s sweet, but in the best possible way—the kind of dish that requires a strong cup of coffee to balance it out.
The Details That Matter
We also ordered a side of their fresh orange juice. It was bright and tasted freshly squeezed—a small but significant detail that shows their dedication to quality. The accompanying home fries were crispy and well-seasoned, the perfect savory sidekick to the eggs. Every element on the plate felt carefully considered and fresh.
Final Verdict: A New Weekend Tradition
Pegasus Restaurant is a local favorite for good reason. It delivers delicious, high-quality, and generous meals in an atmosphere that is genuinely happy and welcoming. It's easy to see why Bay Ridge locals have made this their go-to spot.
For a perfect weekend brunch that satisfies both your comfort food cravings and your desire for something elevated, Pegasus is the winner. My partner and I already have plans to return to try the Greek Benny next!
Location: 8610 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY.
Comments